Precursors To Thanksgiving
Bodie Hodge, M.Sc., B.Sc., PEI
Biblical Authority Ministries, November 16, 2026 (Donate)
Oh, give thanks to the LORD, for He
is good! For His mercy endures forever. And say, “Save us, O God of our
salvation; Gather us together, and deliver us from the Gentiles, To give thanks
to Your holy name, To triumph in Your praise.” (1 Chronicles 16, 34-35, NKJV)
Thanksgiving is right around the corner. It conjures
thoughts of the Mayflower Compact and the famed Congressional Committee proclamation.
But here I wanted to drop back into the history of the events leading up to the
first Thanksgiving. Most of this is easy to find historically, so let me try to
sum up the history in a laymen, easy-to-read fashion. Let’s venture to the
1600s!
From The Protestant Reformation To The Pilgrims' First
Thanksgiving
Thanksgiving stretches back well before the Pilgrims
arrived in America in 1620. First, we must examine the Protestant Reformation,
the rise of the Puritans, their persecution in England, their journey to the
Netherlands, and their eventual voyage to the New World. The Pilgrims had a godly
desire to worship and honor God in accordance with Scripture and give Him the glory,
even through terrible hardships.
Who Were The Puritans?
Okay, so the Puritans in England were a group of 16th
century descendants of the Protestant Reformation. They believed the Church of
England (Anglican Church) hadn’t gone far enough in removing Roman Catholic
traditions and practices. Their desire was to "purify" the church by
bringing its doctrine, worship, and government into closer conformity with the
Bible.
Puritans stood on the authority of Scripture, salvation by
grace through faith in Jesus Christ, biblical preaching, personal holiness, and
godly living. Many were influenced by Reformed theologians such as John Calvin.
Not all Puritans agreed on church government. Some favored
Presbyterian leadership by elders, while others supported congregational
independence. The English Presbyterian movement and, later, the Particular
Baptists shared important theological and historical connections with English
Puritanism. However, Baptist origins were more complex, and not all Baptists
descended directly from Puritans.
Furthermore, there were even division of Puritans. The
Pilgrims were a particular group of Puritans who were labelled “Separatists”. This
is because they wanted “separation” from the Anglicans and their style of
worship and practices—even though they agreed on a great many things! Unlike
Puritans who wanted to reform the Church of England from within, Separatists
believed they needed to leave it entirely and establish independent
congregations.
How Were The Puritans And Anglicans Different From Other
Protestants?
The Protestant Reformation had several major variants,
including the four main ones: Lutheran, Reformed, Anglican, and Anabaptist
traditions. Puritanism developed largely within the English Reformed tradition.
Lutherans: Followed Martin
Luther's reforms, specifically justification by faith but retaining certain
traditional liturgical practices.
Anglicans: Established as
England's national church, retaining bishops, formal liturgy, and some
traditional ceremonies like the Lutherans but also unique form them.
Anabaptists: Rejected infant
baptism, stood on believers' baptism, and generally advocated separation of
church and state. Where Anglicans merged the two having the King or Queen as
the head of both the state and the church.
Reformed/Puritans: Sought
further biblical reform of English worship and church government, wanting more
preaching and godly discipline mimicking the early church.
Although they disagreed over baptism, church government, and
worship, these variations of teachings and practices became heavily debated and
caused further splits.
Why Were There Tensions Between Anglicans And Puritans?
The Church of England separated from papal authority under
King Henry VIII in the 1530s. However, the church retained ranking bishops,
elaborate ceremonies, prescribed prayers, as well as other traditions that the
Puritans felt were left-overs from Rome.
Puritans objected to practices that they firmly believed
lacked biblical justification. For instance, they questioned religious
vestments, ceremonial rituals, and the authority of bishops. They also resisted
the government's power to dictate how congregations should worship.
Under Queen Elizabeth I and later King James I, religious
conformity was actually enforced through laws and ecclesiastical (church) authorities.
They were rather strict. Ministers who refused to conform could lose their
positions, face fines, be imprisoned, or worse!
Separatists, like the Puritans specifically, faced a lot of difficulties
because they established congregations outside the official church. Some
worshiped secretly, risking punishment for their convictions. It almost reminds
you of how the early church had meet to avoid Roman imposition. Yet both were
Protestant denominations!
Why Did The Pilgrims Flee To The Netherlands?
By the early 1600s, a Separatist congregation in Scrooby,
England, faced increasing pressure from the Anglican authorities. Two of their leaders
were William Brewster and John Robinson.
In 1607, an attempted departure from England failed, and
some members were arrested. In 1608, the congregation successfully escaped to
the Netherlands, where religious toleration was greater and they could freely
worship Jesus Christ without persecution.
They initially settled in Amsterdam—the largest city, before
relocating to Leiden in 1609. Although they enjoyed greater freedom to worship,
life was still difficult. They left family, lands, jobs and essentially started
over. Thus, many had to worked long hours in textile manufacturing and other
trades. Economic opportunities were limited, and the congregation worried that
its children were gradually adopting Dutch language and other, not-so-godly customs.
So they wanted the freedom to establish a community where
they could preserve their religious convictions and godly heritage for future
generations. Then they arrived at the idea establish a settlement/colony in America/the
New World.
The Mayflower And Speedwell: The Journey To America
In July 1620, the Pilgrims departed the Netherlands aboard
the Speedwell, a smaller vessel intended to accompany the larger Mayflower
across the Atlantic.
The ships met at Southampton, England, where additional
passengers and supplies were gathered. But their voyage encountered serious
difficulties—leaks!
The Speedwell began springing serious leak, forcing
both ships to return to Dartmouth for repairs. After departing again, the Speedwell
continued taking on water. It simply wasn’t same. The vessels returned to
Plymouth, England, where the smaller ship was abandoned (it wasn’t “speed-well”
after all!).
Finally, on September 6, 1620 (September 16 on the modern
Gregorian calendar), the Mayflower departed alone with 102 passengers.
The Atlantic crossing took about 66 days and included dangerous storms, crowded
conditions, seasickness, and damage to the ship. But they made it.
Landing In America And The First Winter
On November 11, 1620 (November 21 by the modern calendar), the Pilgrims arrived near Cape Cod, Massachusetts, far north of their intended destination near the Hudson River. After exploring the coastline, they established Plymouth Colony in December.
Their first winter was truly devastating. They faced
freezing temperatures, no shelter, disease, exhaustion, and limited fresh food
and supplies. Many remained aboard the Mayflower while shelters were generically
constructed. Sadly, by the spring of 1621, approximately half the passengers
had died (50 total), leaving on 52, and they were barely hanging on.
Yet the surviving Pilgrims persevered. They began
interacting with a local Native American tribe. And this began a new friendship
and they became allies, particularly through Tisquantum (Squanto). He specifically
helped them learn to grow local crops and berries. The alliance with the
Wampanoag, and their leader Ousamequin (Massasoit) also really helped the
colony to survive after this.
Giving God The Glory: The Mayflower Compact
Before establishing their settlement in America, the adult men
signed the Mayflower Compact. Its opening declared:
"In the name of God,
Amen."
The document explained that their voyage was undertaken:
"For the Glory of God, and
Advancement of the Christian Faith"
The Compact set in motion a civil government in which the
settlers agreed to cooperate and enact laws for the general good of the colony
(based on the Bible). This incredible document showed the faith in God that the
Pilgrims had. They openly acknowledged God and understood their undertaking as
a Christian endeavor.
The First Thanksgiving Of 1621
Following a successful harvest in the Autumn of 1621, the
Pilgrims celebrated with a gathering lasting about three days. This godly
celebration included about 90 Wampanoag men, including Massasoit, along with
the surviving colonists. The celebration included food, fellowship, and fun.
The Pilgrims rightly understood their survival and harvest
as blessings from God's providence. Their Christian convictions came full
circle to give thanks to God in both prosperity and adversity.
Final Remarks
Enter into His gates with
thanksgiving, And into His courts with praise. Be thankful to Him, and bless
His name. (Psalm 100:4, NKJV)
Thanksgiving's history should be a reminder to all of us
Christians that the Pilgrims endured religious persecution, exile, dangerous
voyages, disease, and the deaths of loved ones. Yet they continued to
acknowledge and honor God's and His providence.
Their account should also remind us of the importance of our
religious convictions—particularly standing on the authority of God’s Word even
in persecution. And we should be thankful to God for it.
For Christians today, Thanksgiving should be more than
turkey, football, and family gatherings. Don’t get me wrong, these things are
all wonderful blessings, but it should be an opportunity to thank our Lord as
the source of our blessings including the greatest gift—salvation through Jesus Christ our Lord.
As Psalm 107:1 declares:
Oh, give thanks to the LORD, for He
is good! For His mercy endures forever. (NKJV)
□
Bodie Hodge, Ken Ham's son in law, has been an apologist
defending 6-day creation and opposing evolution since 1998. He spent 21 years
working at Answers in Genesis as a speaker, writer, and
researcher as well as a founding news anchor for Answers News. He
was also head of the Oversight Council.
Bodie launched Biblical Authority Ministries in
2015 as a personal website and it was organized officially in 2025 as a
501(c)(3). He has spoken on multiple continents and hosts of US states in
churches, colleges, and universities. He is married with four children.
Mr. Hodge earned a Bachelor and Master of Science degrees
from Southern Illinois University at Carbondale (SIUC). Then he taught
at SIUC for a couple of years as a Visiting Instructor teaching all levels of
undergraduate engineering and running a materials lab and a CAD lab. He did
research on advanced ceramic materials to develop a new method of production of
titanium diboride with a grant from Lockheed Martin. He worked as a Test
Engineer for Caterpillar, Inc., prior to entering full-time ministry.
His love of science was coupled with a love of history,
philosophy, and theology. For about one year of his life, Bodie was editing and
updating a theological, historical, and scientific dictionary/encyclopedia. Mr.
Hodge has over 25 years of experience in writing, speaking and researching in
these fields.
*Image by generative program as requested by Bodie Hodge












